Okay, gave the roasting items another stir, so time for another quick post. I tricked my husband into seeing the cultural touchstone that is Twilight for our date night. Hey, I admit it: I’m full-on too, too old to have read these books, but read them I did. Well, “read” may be too mild a word, I was a Twilight tweaker! I was afraid the movie would really be terrible, but it wasn’t. My husband’s great compliment, “It wasn’t nearly as bad as I thought it would be.” My concern went in another direction. One of the great lures of the books is how completely adolescent they are. We all like to look back and think of ourselves as young women with a purpose, little proto-feminists. Right. Most of us were just walking, stammering nerve-endings whose every interaction with the world was so painfully small in its emotional enormity. We wanted to be invisible yet showered with adoration and accolades. We moved in hurricanes of feelings that waged destruction and fed on themselves. Twilight is Titanic with a lower budget, less CGI, and no sinking ship–everything is all high stakes, all the time, and nothing about the relationships makes sense. But, of course, this makes perfect sense . . . or should I invoke Austen and say that it makes “sensibility.” I thought Catherine Hardwicke’s choice to foreground close-up whenever possible was perfect: the tight focus encourages heady devotion by foreclosing any perspective. Ah, youth. Earlier last week, we had a conference with our daughter’s teachers (first grade). She runs with a small group of girls that have been together for three years. I told one of her teachers that she was about to enter the years when groups of girls oscillate between being “a host of angels and a nest of vipers.” She leaned back a bit, smiled, laughed, and said, “So true.” The Twilight books have really rubbed some feminists the wrong way, and I wonder if part of this isn’t just the grown-up woman’s wish that she wasn’t once a young girl fighting (to paraphrase Wilson) such big battles over such small stakes. I’d rather remember that we somehow got through those romantic wars, and now that we’re on the other side, we can look back wisely, with Mona Lisa grins of secret knowledge won at great cost and great reward.
Tags
Archives
